| 2 | — | Caught Red-handed | - | Base card | — | — |
| 3 | — | Hate…the Beginning of a Love Story | - | Base card | — | — |
| 4 | — | Elena Cares for Stefan | - | Base card | — | — |
| 5 | — | Tyler’s Anger | - | Base card | — | — |
| 6 | — | Friendly Competition | - | Base card | — | — |
| 7 | — | You Suck | - | Base card | — | — |
| 8 | — | Caroline Sees Matt | - | Base card | — | — |
| 9 | — | What Is Wrong with Me? | - | Base card | — | — |
| 10 | — | Searching for Answers | - | Base card | — | — |
| 11 | — | Dig Deeper | - | Base card | — | — |
| 12 | — | A Werewolf and a Full Moon | - | Base card | — | — |
| 13 | — | Misdirection | - | Base card | — | — |
| 14 | — | A New Enemy | - | Base card | — | — |
| 15 | — | DoppelgAnger | - | Base card | — | — |
| 16 | — | Bad Day. Bad Century. | - | Base card | — | — |
| 17 | — | White Flag | - | Base card | — | — |
| 18 | — | A Secret Revealed | - | Base card | — | — |
| 19 | — | Hi | Mom. | - | — | — |
| 20 | — | Plan to Kill | - | Base card | — | — |
| 21 | — | A Budding Romance | - | Base card | — | — |
| 22 | — | A Masked Threat | - | Base card | — | — |
| 23 | — | Feel That? | - | Base card | — | — |
| 24 | — | My Witch Is Better Than Yours | - | Base card | — | — |
| 25 | — | Road Trip Bonding | - | Base card | — | — |
| 26 | — | Elijah Meets Elena | - | Base card | — | — |
| 27 | — | Elena’s Rescue | - | Base card | — | — |
| 28 | — | Elijah Staked | - | Base card | — | — |
| 29 | — | Distraction | - | Base card | — | — |
| 30 | — | Doppelgänger Pursuit | - | Base card | — | — |
| 31 | — | A New Spell | - | Base card | — | — |
| 32 | — | Burning the Portrait | - | Base card | — | — |
| 33 | — | Dr. Jonas Martin | - | Base card | — | — |
| 34 | — | Bump in the Night | - | Base card | — | — |
| 35 | — | Transformation | - | Base card | — | — |
| 36 | — | New Info | - | Base card | — | — |
| 37 | — | Elena’s Failed Plan | - | Base card | — | — |
| 38 | — | Exploring the Cellar | - | Base card | — | — |
| 39 | — | You’ve Been Marked | - | Base card | — | — |
| 40 | — | Aftermath | - | Base card | — | — |
| 41 | — | Wolf Bite | - | Base card | — | — |
| 42 | — | Hallucination | - | Base card | — | — |
| 43 | — | Farewell | - | Base card | — | — |
| 44 | — | Stefan Traps Tyler | - | Base card | — | — |
| 45 | — | Alliance | - | Base card | — | — |
| 46 | — | Rescuing Caroline | - | Base card | — | — |
| 47 | — | Romantic Weekend | - | Base card | — | — |
| 48 | — | Elijah Smith | - | Base card | — | — |
| 49 | — | Stefan and Damon at Odds | - | Base card | — | — |
| 50 | — | Daggering an Original | - | Base card | — | — |
| 51 | — | Finding Elena | - | Base card | — | — |
| 52 | — | Playing Elena | - | Base card | — | — |
| 53 | — | Astral Projection | - | Base card | — | — |
| 54 | — | A Couple’s Fight | - | Base card | — | — |
| 55 | — | A Declaration | - | Base card | — | — |
| 56 | — | An Epic Moment | - | Base card | — | — |
| 57 | — | Newfound Magic | - | Base card | — | — |
| 58 | — | The 60s | - | Base card | — | — |
| 59 | — | Picking an Outfit | - | Base card | — | — |
| 60 | — | Flirting with Danger | - | Base card | — | — |
| 61 | — | Learning the Truth | - | Base card | — | — |
| 62 | — | Brothers at Odds | - | Base card | — | — |
| 63 | — | An Alternate Plan | - | Base card | — | — |
| 64 | — | Matt’s Ruse | - | Base card | — | — |
| 65 | — | Meeting Klaus | - | Base card | — | — |
| 66 | — | A Final Confession | - | Base card | — | — |
| 67 | — | The Sacrifice Ritual | - | Base card | — | — |
| 68 | — | A Vampire | a Werewolf | and the Doppelgänger | — | — |
| 69 | — | Checklist | - | Base card | — | — |
| A1 | — | Nina Dobrev as Elena Gilbert/Katherine Pierce | Autographs | Base card | — | — |
| A2 | — | Paul Wesley as Stefan Salvatore | Autographs | Base card | — | — |
| A3 | — | Ian Somerhalder as Damon Salvatore | Autographs | Base card | — | — |
| A4 | — | Steven R. McQueen as Jeremy Gilbert | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A5 | — | Kat Graham as Bonnie Bennett | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A6 | — | Candice Accola as Caroline Forbes | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A7 | — | Zach Roerig as Matt Donovan | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A8 | — | Michael Trevino as Tyler Lockwood | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A9 | — | Matt Davis as Alaric Saltzman | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A10 | — | Joseph Morgan as Klaus | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A11 | — | Sara Canning as Jenna Sommers | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A12 | — | Daniel Gillies as Elijah | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A13 | — | Michaela McManus as Jules | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A14 | — | Taylor Kinney as Mason Lockwood | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A15 | — | Lauren Cohan as Rose | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A16 | — | Bryton James as Luka Martin | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A17 | — | Randy J. Goodwin as Dr. Jonas Martin | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A18 | — | Trent Ford as Trevor | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A19 | — | Dawn Olivieri as Andie Star | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A20 | — | Susan Walters as Carol Lockwood | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| A21 | — | Marguerite MacIntyre as Sheriff Liz Forbes | Autographs | Chase card | — | — |
| BTS1 | — | Time to Wolf Out | Behind the Scenes | Chase card | — | — |
| BTS2 | — | Time Between Takes | Behind the Scenes | Chase card | — | — |
| BTS3 | — | Fist Bump | Behind the Scenes | Chase card | — | — |
| BTS4 | — | Girl Bonding | Behind the Scenes | Chase card | — | — |
| BTS5 | — | The Triangle Bonding | Behind the Scenes | Chase card | — | — |
| BTS6 | — | Katerina | Behind the Scenes | Chase card | — | — |
| BTS7 | — | What Now? | Behind the Scenes | Chase card | — | — |
| BTS8 | — | Sacrifice | Behind the Scenes | Chase card | — | — |
| BTS9 | — | Point for Katherine | Behind the Scenes | Chase card | — | — |
| DM1 | — | Mason Lockwood Played by Taylor Kenney / Sheriff Forbes Played by Marguerrite MacIntyre | Dual Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| DM2 | — | Damon Salvatore Played by Ian Somerhalder / Stefan Salvatore Played by Paul Wesley | Dual Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| DM3 | — | Elena Gilbert Played by Nina Dobrev / Stefan Salvatore Played by Paul Wesley | Dual Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| DM4 | — | Matt Donovan Played by Zach Roerig / Caroline Forbes Played by Candice Accola | Dual Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| DM5 | — | Elena Gilbert Played by Nina Dobrev / Damon Salvatore Played by Ian Somerhalder | Dual Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| DM6 | — | Jeremy Gilbert Played by Steven R. McQueen / Bonnie Bennett Played by Kat Graham | Dual Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| KP1 | — | Mystery Girl | Katerina Petrova | Chase card | — | — |
| KP2 | — | Waiting | Katerina Petrova | Chase card | — | — |
| KP3 | — | Call Me Klaus | Katerina Petrova | Chase card | — | — |
| KP4 | — | The Original Brothers and Katerina | Katerina Petrova | Chase card | — | — |
| KP5 | — | Entertaining Katerina | Katerina Petrova | Chase card | — | — |
| KP6 | — | True Love | Katerina Petrova | Chase card | — | — |
| KP7 | — | Return Home | Katerina Petrova | Chase card | — | — |
| M1 | — | Tyler Lockwood as played by Michael Trevino | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M2 | — | Caroline Forbes as played by Candice Accola | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M3 | — | Caroline Forbes as played by Candice Accola | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M4 | — | Mason Lockwood as played by Taylor Kenney | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M5 | — | Sheriff Forbes as played by Marguerrite MacIntyre | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M6 | — | Stefan Salvatore as played by Paul Wesley | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M7 | — | Damon Salvatore as played by Ian Somerhalder | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M8 | — | Stefan Salvatore as played by Paul Wesley | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M9 | — | Elena Gilbert as played by Nina Dobrev | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M10 | — | Damon Salvatore as played by Ian Somerhalder | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M11 | — | Katherine Pierce as played by Nina Dobrev | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M12 | — | Rose as played by Lauren Cohan | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M13 | — | Jules as played by Michaela McManus | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M14 | — | Jenna Sommers as played by Sara Canning | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M15 | — | Jeremy Gilbert as played by Steven R. McQueen | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M16 | — | Rose as played by Lauren Cohan | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M17 | — | Katherine Pierce as played by Nina Dobrev | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M18 | — | Luka as played by Bryton James | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M19 | — | Tyler Lockwood as played by Michael Trevino | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M20 | — | Elena Gilbert as played by Nina Dobrev | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M21 | — | Caroline Forbes as played by Candice Accola | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M22 | — | Jules as played by Michaela McManus | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M23 | — | Bonnie Bennett as played by Kat Graham | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M24 | — | Luka as played by Bryton James | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M25 | — | Elena Gilbert as played by Nina Dobrev | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M26 | — | Mason Lockwood as played by Taylor Kenney | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M27 | — | Matt Donovan as Zach Roerig | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M28 | — | Sheriff Forbes as played by Marguerrite MacIntyre | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M29 | — | Elena Gilbert as played by Nina Dobrev | Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| M30 | — | Stefan as played by Paul Wesley / Katherine as played by Nina Dobrev / Damon as played by Ian Somerhalber | Triple Wardrobe | Chase card | — | — |
| P1 | — | Stefan / Elena / Damon (faces) | Non-Sport Update (August/September | 2012) | — | — |
| P2 | — | Stefan / Elena / Damon (fully-body) | Philly Non-Sports Card Show | Promo card | — | — |
